What makes a post valuable?

This is a question that has been asked by Alice  MacGillivray in one of the CPsquare community forums and an interesting discussion is going on there. It seemed to me that this question is very relevant to recent discussions in some people’s blogs about reasons for blogging. Do discussions happen in blogs or is it a different type of communication? Alice’s question was about posts made in any context, e.g, blogs, twitter, discussion forums etc.

In relation to blogging, this question gets at why people might receive comments on their blog.

This was my response to Alice in the CPsquare forum in relation to my work as an online tutor:

Hi Alice – this is a really interesting question. I work online all the time, as an online facilitator for HE courses in the UK, so this question is one I am always asking myself. What will my students find meaningful or valuable?  I think we need to separate out meaningful from valuable and perhaps understand what we mean by these terms.

Thinking about how to answer your question, I have gone to my own experience online. For me, the post has to resonate with my own experience in some way. It has to make a connection, either to my understanding and experience of the subject or in a social capacity. This initial connection makes the post meaningful and makes me read on.

Deciding whether a post is valuable or not is slightly different. I have to relate the post to my own context, experience and needs and determine whether the post will have an effect on any of these.  As a tutor online I try to connect with my student. To do this I try to find out as much as I can about them so that I can connect with them on a personal level and post something that resonates with their experience and is meaningful. I think this initial relationship building can help successive posts to become more meaningful and hopefully valuable.

Whether or not my posts are valuable is more complicated. It depends on my level of experience, knowledge, understanding and expertise compared to theirs and whether or not what I have to say fits their current context of what they need.

This was a quick and  ‘off the top of my head’ response to Alice, and there is obviously a lot more to it than this. Definitely worth further thought.

4 thoughts on “What makes a post valuable?

  1. Sui Fai John Mak February 20, 2009 / 8:57 am

    Many thanks for your insights on what makes a post valuable. I have tried applying the “8 hats” in analysing blogging and on-line discussion.
    This is the result of our collaboration. I greatly appreciate your inspiration on this. I would not have thought about such interpretation and analysis without your lead.

  2. Mike Bogle February 20, 2009 / 8:46 pm

    Hi Jenny,

    Chaotic morning here so I’d better be brief here – the thought just occurred to me that perhaps instead of looking at blogs as a singular space for discussion it instead becomes just one part of a larger whole.

    For example my colleagues and I have been grappling with the notion of network literacies lately, and the discussion is spread across blog comments, tweets (twitter posts), emails, face to face discussion, and wiki articles. All of these combine to make a really vibrant, indepth discussion, but taken on their own the comments on blogs may not appear to progress things very far.

    I’ve begun to consider the notion of transcending technology, and the idea that conversation don’t really respect technical boundaries. This seems to be in keeping with that idea I think.

    So perhaps rather than saying discussions happen ON blogs, we should start thinking of discussions as taking place THROUGH blogs (along with other mediums); and the notion that even the briefest of comments still progresses the conversation when looking at the big picture.

    What do you think?



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s