Finding and losing your voice in the collective

‘How do we find the knowledge that we need in the collective space?’

‘What are the binding forces that bring knowledge resources and people together?’

These two questions have been raised this week by Allison Littlejohn – in Change Mooc 11 –  and also discussed with Lou McGill .

Reference to ‘binding forces’ made my ears prick up, but I have been struggling to further resonate with the ideas that have been presented.  Allison and her team’s interests lie around identifying the social objects that help people to bind together in collective environments, and increasing our understanding of the tools, skills and processes that are needed to learn in complex connective environments/collectives.

But for me Lou McGill’s question –  about how to balance the needs of me as an individual with the needs of the broader collective is more interesting.

Whilst we do need to ask (and answer) questions about the social objects that will bring people together and the digital literacy skills that they will need to find each other, these are ‘what’ questions, rather than ‘how’ questions.

When Matthias Melcher and I wrote our paper on online resonance – we were interested in the ‘how’ of online connections. Although we were interested in one-to-one resonance as opposed to ‘binding forces’ in groups/collectives, I think the ideas we were struggling with were/are relevant to this discussion. We explored how people connect with each other online in some depth,  concluding that there definitely is something that sparks off connections, which we called ‘e-resonance’. We suggested that as well as recognizing the skills that learners need and the affordances of the web for this resonance to occur, we also need to try and unpick/understand the contributing elements of ‘beyond verbal’ communication. In relation to this discussion – would this also be ‘beyond social object’?

I think it was this deeper level of communication or binding that I was looking for in Allison’s work. Whilst we might be able to identify a task, assignment or learning goal as being the social object around which people appear to collect, I think the actual binding (particularly if that binding is going to be long-term) has to be at a deeper and more individual level. Whilst the collective may be made up of a whole array of resources, it is also made up of individuals, whose learning will be determined by their perceptions of their individual identities in relation to the collective.

I’m with Lou in her concerns about the individual getting lost in the collective.

Thanks to Allison for a very well prepared and thought provoking presentation for ChangeMOOC.

4 thoughts on “Finding and losing your voice in the collective

  1. allison littlejohn October 10, 2011 / 10:07 pm

    Dear Jenny

    I enjoyed reading your ideas on online resonance.

    Through our research we have gathered (limited) empirical data on the drivers for creating/contributing knowledge in the workplace. Perhaps some of these ideas could feed into your online resonance work?

    Margaryan, A., Milligan, C., & Littlejohn, A. (2009). Self-regulated learning and knowledge sharing in the workplace: Differences and similarities between experts and novices. In Proceedings of the 2009 Researching Work and Learning (RWL) Conference, Roskilde, Denmark.

    Margaryan, A., Milligan, C., Litteljohn, A., Hendrix, D., & Graeb-Koenneker, S. (2009). Self-regulated learning and knowledge sharing in the workplace. In Proceedings of the 2009 International Conference on Organisational Learning, Knowledge and Capabilities (OLKC), Amsterdam, Netherlands.

    Click to access 6CAMargaryan.pdf

  2. jennymackness October 11, 2011 / 1:17 pm

    Allison – many thanks for your comment and links to your papers. In the days, weeks, months to come I will be thinking further about the relationship of the individual to the collective and whether it is possible to get empirical evidence to support our ideas on e-resonance.

    I am also keen to explore further your writing on ‘self-regulated’ learning and unpick for myself the differences between this and self-determined learning (which I have been discussing with Carmen Tschofen and Matthias Melcher) and self-organised learning (which I have been discussing with Roy Williams and Regina Karousou).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s